Retiring Partner Goodwill: Capital Asset Treatment or Guaranteed Payment?

⚡ Advisor-Initiated Low

—

🛡️ Senior Advisor

Sarah, thanks for making the time on short notice. I wanted to flag something time-sensitive that could save one of your partners a significant amount of tax, but we need to move quickly if we're going to act on it. I was reviewing the partnership agreement in connection with Tom's upcoming retirement, and I noticed that it's silent on how goodwill gets treated when a partner exits. Under Section…

🔒

Create a free account to keep reading.

It takes 10 seconds.

Create free account Already have one? Sign in

Free accounts get unlimited access to all conversations.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first.

Case Summary ▾

Complexity ⓘ Low

Fact Pattern Law firm partnership with 30 attorneys considered amending partnership agreement to treat retiring founding partner's goodwill as IRC § 736(b) capital asset rather than § 736(a) ordinary income. Two partners had retired in prior five years under § 736(a) formula with no goodwill carve-out. Client relationships were mixed institutional/personal (approximately 50-50 retention expected). Partnership agreement was silent on goodwill treatment and balance sheet did not separately state goodwill value.

Position Taken Partnership maintained existing § 736(a) treatment consistent with prior retirements, declining to amend agreement before retirement date. Entire $2 million payment treated as guaranteed payment generating ordinary income to retiring partner and ordinary deduction to remaining partners. Position supported by established course of dealing across three retirements and absence of separately identifiable institutional goodwill asset on partnership books.

IRS Challenge None identified. IRS examiner closed case with no adjustments, noting that proposed amendment would have created audit exposure under substance-over-form doctrine due to inconsistent treatment versus prior retirements and lack of documented institutional goodwill separate from personal relationships.

Authorities

IRC § 736(a) IRC § 736(b) Treas. Reg. § 1.736-1(a)(2) Treas. Reg. § 1.736-1(b)(3) Revenue Ruling 77-137