Real Estate Workout: Deed-in-Lieu Sale or Disguised Debt Discharge?

Very High

—

🏢 Client

We have a real estate partnership that's about to file for bankruptcy, and I need to understand what happens to the cancellation of debt income when our lender writes down the mortgage. Here's the structure: I'm a 70% LP, my co-investor holds 20%, and the GP has 10%. We own an office building through a Delaware LLC taxed as a partnership, and we're about to negotiate a $15 million principal reduct…

🔒

Create a free account to keep reading.

It takes 10 seconds.

Create free account Already have one? Sign in

Free accounts get unlimited access to all conversations.

Discussion

No comments yet. Be the first.

Case Summary ▾

Complexity ⓘ Very High

Fact Pattern Real estate partnership holding office building (FMV $30M, basis ~$38M, nonrecourse debt $50M) negotiated workout with lender. After learning COD income would trigger unfavorable minimum gain chargeback allocation, partnership pivoted from debt reduction to deed-in-lieu structure to convert $15M ordinary COD income into $12M capital loss under IRC § 7701(g).

Position Taken Deed-in-lieu of foreclosure qualifies as deemed sale with debt as amount realized under IRC § 7701(g), generating capital loss rather than COD income. Position supported by statutory language treating debt satisfaction transfers as sales, avoiding COD income recognition and minimum gain chargeback requirements under Treas. Reg. § 1.704-2(f). However, structure adopted specifically after advisors identified that COD income allocation would be unfavorable, creating significant recharacterization risk.

IRS Challenge Step transaction and substance-over-form recharacterization. IRS will argue transaction was debt discharge followed by deemed disposition, not bona fide deed-in-lieu, based on: (1) contemporaneous negotiations showing partnership was pursuing principal reduction until learning of adverse allocation consequences; (2) lender's indifference between structures with taxpayer driving deed-in-lieu characterization for tax reasons; (3) identical economic outcomes between structures; (4) advisor discussions revealing tax avoidance as primary motivation. IRS will assert $15M ordinary COD income must be recognized and allocated under minimum gain chargeback rules in Treas. Reg. § 1.704-2(f), with any subsequent property disposition treated as separate transaction using debt-reduced basis.

Authorities

IRC § 61(a)(12) IRC § 108(e)(5) IRC § 704(b) IRC § 752 IRC § 7701(g) Treas. Reg. § 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(c) Treas. Reg. § 1.704-2(f) Treas. Reg. § 1.704-1(b)(1)(iii)